by Brian Rutherford
When you sit down at the Thanksgiving table this year, several of the people around you will be anxious, and most of them will look fine.
It took me a long time to understand that anxiety is rarely about the problem a person thinks is causing it.
Most of us operate on a quiet theory that if we could resolve the next challenge in front of us, the worry would lift. The challenge might be money, a kid’s grades, a job, a health scare, or an aging parent.
So we go to work on it. We make the calls, run the numbers, and have the hard conversations, and sometimes we succeed. The situation gets handled, and the anxiety does not go away.
Within about a week the anxiety has attached itself to something else.
If the kid’s grades came up, now the worry is the rattle you heard in the car this morning. If the money stabilized, now the worry is the mole on your shoulder. We settle one concern and the anxiety simply picks up the next one.
For that reason, I have started to think of anxiety less like a signal and more like a parasite. A parasite needs a host. When one host dies, the parasite jumps to the next one, and the host was never the point.
Anxiety behaves the same way. Whatever we are worried about today is only the current host.
This matters for church leaders because anxiety is not confined to a few people in your church. It is an epidemic across American life, and your congregation is not exempt. It shows up in the single mom who cannot catch up, in the retiree who cannot sleep, and in the person who has everything together on the outside and is white-knuckling it through every Sunday.
Seeing anxiety as a parasite helps. Once you recognize that it is only looking for its next host, you stop believing it when it insists that today’s worry is the one that matters.
You also begin to see something larger: resolving every challenge will never bring you to a peaceful life, because life is a series of challenges and there is no finish line where the last one gets handled.
That is why the biblical answer to anxiety was never to solve more problems. Paul wrote, “Do not be anxious about anything, but in every situation, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, present your requests to God” (Philippians 4:6).
The life Paul describes is not a solved life. It is a life lived with God in the middle of our troubles rather than on the other side of them. Jesus did not promise to clear the road ahead of us, but he did promise the Holy Spirit to walk the road with us.
Notice that thanksgiving sits in the middle of Paul’s instruction. He does not treat gratitude as a nice sentiment for one Thursday in November. He treats it as part of how an anxious person prays.
Naming what God has already done is how we remember who we are talking to.
All of this raises a question for church leaders, and it is a question bigger than one post can hold. Are the sermons and lessons you teach mostly helping people solve their difficulties with good principles, or are they teaching people how to live their everyday lives with Jesus?
Next week your church will sit at tables full of anxious people. It is a good week to help them pray the way Paul described.
If you want a more structured way to do that work, the Radical Alignment Assessment (alignmychurch.com) gives your team a common framework to rate where you actually are — together — before you talk about where you're going.